Television

Blue Bloods Season 12 Episode 17 Review: Hidden Motive


master mentalism tricks

What is Mayor Chase up to?

On Blue Bloods Season 12 Episode 17, Jamie and Frank argued after Chase secretly tapped Jamie to be his new head of security.

Jamie was sure Chase was making this move to get revenge on Frank for perceived wrongs, but I didn’t quite get how that would work.

An Unexpected Request / Tall - Blue Bloods

Frank said that Chase’s interest in Jamie wasn’t as straightforward as wanting him because he was a Reagan.

That much made sense. Jamie has proven himself to be an exemplary cop who has come a long way in a short time.

It wasn’t that long ago that he was a beat cop who didn’t have any interest in anything more than that. Now he’s a sergeant in charge of a dozen or more cops who does his best to balance work and family interests.

Anyone would be proud to work with him, including Mayor Chase.

A Wealthy Victim - Blue Bloods Season 12 Episode 17

Chase tried to do an end-run around Frank to make this request, probably because he assumed Frank would have a problem with it. But where I’m lost is why Jamie was upset with Frank over it.

Jamie: You didn’t think to give me a heads-up?
Frank: I didn’t know he was going to call you. So am I supposed to give a heads-up to every cop who might be transferred, or just you?
Jamie: I didn’t say that.
Frank: I can read the room.

Jamie got mad at Frank for not giving him a heads-up — something Frank only chose to do because he was following protocol rather than giving Jamie special treatment.

I got that Jamie didn’t like being left out of decisions that influenced his career and that he felt that if Frank knew about it, he should have told him. But I still don’t get what that had to do with Chase trying to stick it to Frank.

Sure, Chase insulted Frank by routing his request through Sid and not talking to him directly, but so what?

The Wrong Path - Blue Bloods Season 12 Episode 17

Was Chase hoping that Jamie accepting the job would cause a rift with Frank? And if so, that could easily be solved by Frank and Jamie talking honestly, as they did at the end of the hour.

Frank also indicated that this had something to do with Chase’s gubernatorial aspirations.

I guess he’s choosing the people he wants to accompany him to the governor’s mansion should he be elected, but I’m still not sure what that has to do with his decision not to tell Frank directly that he wanted Jamie to be part of that team.

The conflict here was confusing. I’d rather Jamie had spent his time being conflicted about what to do without being upset that Frank didn’t tell him ahead of time that he had a decision to make.

Scrambling to Help His Half Brother - Blue Bloods Season 12 Episode 17

Meanwhile, Anthony’s story about Leo was ostensibly about his fear that Leo was rejoining the mob.

Anthony didn’t do much investigating into that, though. Instead, he focused on trying to get Leo financial help so that he wouldn’t have to depend on money from a mobster.

Erin: A medical loan?
Anthony: Eavesdrop much?
Erin: It wasn’t intentional.

This story served as comic relief more than anything else. I laughed at Leo’s bemused reactions when his girlfriend went into labor. Something tells me these two are going to need a lot of help and that Anthony may have trouble staying on top of his work for the next little bit.

Thankfully, the Anthony vs. Erin part of this story was kept to a minimum. Anthony is still mad that Erin stalked him a while back, and Erin is still putting her nose into his business, but that’s easier to take in small doses.

The Mayor Blindsides Frank - Blue Bloods

Eddie and Badillo’s case was one of the more interesting stories of the hour.

Blue Bloods often tackles common social problems from the cops’ perspective, and this story was no different. Instead of showing the Youtuber as a hero who successfully stood up to police abuse of power, this story was about a troublemaker who tried to provoke cops so that his audience could cheer him on while he fought with them.

He was obnoxious, annoying, and entitled, and I was glad that Eddie arrested him. Free speech has never meant that you can say whatever you want without consequences, something which agitators on both sides of the political spectrum seem to have lost sight of, and the guy deserved to get arrested.

I didn’t like Badillo’s attitude, though it demonstrated how much pressure cops are often under, thanks to their poor public image.

The Mayor's Security Detail - This Is Us - Blue Bloods

He shouldn’t have blamed Eddie for any of what went down. She didn’t “take the bait.” If anything, she was trying to keep Badillo from getting into trouble. The incident happened fast, but he seemed more upset than she did while it was happening, making it doubly ridiculous for him to accuse her of hotheaded or impulsive behavior.

It’s always fun when Henry shows up to save the day, though, and he did it in more ways than one this time!

I heard you think that Reagans are all goody-two-shoes and hotheads. Well, you’re not wrong. But we do come in other colors. Keep your eyes open and you just might see it.

Henry

If anyone could put Badillo in his place, it was Henry. He has a way of smiling and speaking gently while subtly twisting the knife. He used the same techniques that got that Youtuber to take his video down to warn Badillo to stop judging Eddie or the rest of the Reagans.

Finally, Danny and Maria’s case of the week was bizarre.

This case seemed goofy from the get-go, with a rookie cop who couldn’t even tell the difference between an unconscious victim and a dead one. Maria was upset about the Spences’ arguments during the investigation, but I just wanted them to be quiet!

And when Grace woke up, the case was easily solved. But I was half expecting it to be that newbie cop. I thought maybe he mistook her for a perp and hit her, then realized she actually lived there.

That guy was so green I wouldn’t have put it past him!

The real solution was far less interesting. It was a robbery gone wrong, and the Spences’ faithful driver turned out to have been behind it.

We’ve seen something like this before on Blue Bloods, and I wasn’t attached to any of these characters enough to care about this.

Your turn, Blue Bloods fanatics. Hit that big, blue SHOW COMMENTS button and let us know your thoughts about Blue Bloods Season 12 Episode 17.

If you missed the episode, watch Blue Bloods online right here on TV Fanatic.

Blue Bloods airs on CBS on Fridays at 10 PM EST / PST.

Jack Ori is a senior staff writer for TV Fanatic. His debut young adult novel, Reinventing Hannah, is available on Amazon. Follow him on Twitter.

Read The Full Article Here


trick photography
Billy Crystal, Kate Hudson and More Stars Celebrate Palisades Village Reopening After L.A. Fires
Billy Crystal, Kate Hudson and More Stars Celebrate Palisades Village Reopening After L.A. Fires
Tori Spelling Details Worst Filming Experience With Director Who Left Her Hoping Shed be Fired
Tori Spelling Details Worst Filming Experience With Director Who Left Her Hoping Shed be Fired
Adam Scotts Birthday Tribute To Naomi Scott Is Pure Unfiltered Adoration
Adam Scotts Birthday Tribute To Naomi Scott Is Pure Unfiltered Adoration
Dua Lipa Says Surviving New York City Summer Heat Is an Olympic Sport
Dua Lipa Says Surviving New York City Summer Heat Is an Olympic Sport
The Movies and Shows That Inspired Lanterns
The Movies and Shows That Inspired Lanterns
Reckon with the Flesh: The Fly at 40
Reckon with the Flesh: The Fly at 40
Locker Diaries: Descendants New Episodes & More Disney+ Releases This Week
Locker Diaries: Descendants New Episodes & More Disney+ Releases This Week
Meet the Festival Director: Edinburgh International Film Festival 2026
Meet the Festival Director: Edinburgh International Film Festival 2026
Casting News: Industry Adds 7 To Final Season, Scrubs Casts SNL Vet As New Chief Resident, And More – TVLine
Casting News: Industry Adds 7 To Final Season, Scrubs Casts SNL Vet As New Chief Resident, And More – TVLine
Hayden Panettiere, Heroes And Nashville Star, Dead At 36 – TVLine
Hayden Panettiere, Heroes And Nashville Star, Dead At 36 – TVLine
No Preview
15 Most Unnecessary TV Character Deaths – TVLine
Rocky Kramer’s Rock & Roll Tuesdays Presents  “A Kind of Magic” On Tuesday, August 18th, 2026 7 PM PT on Twitch
Rocky Kramer’s Rock & Roll Tuesdays Presents  “A Kind of Magic” On Tuesday, August 18th, 2026 7 PM PT on Twitch
LL Cool J, SWV, Lil Kim, Method Man & Redman to Headline Thanksgiving Edition of Rock the Bells
LL Cool J, SWV, Lil Kim, Method Man & Redman to Headline Thanksgiving Edition of Rock the Bells
The 11 Best 1970s Glam Rock Albums (Ranked)
The 11 Best 1970s Glam Rock Albums (Ranked)
Rocky Kramer’s Rock & Roll Tuesdays Presents  “A Kind of Magic” On Tuesday, August 18th, 2026 7 PM PT on Twitch
Rocky Kramer’s Rock & Roll Tuesdays Presents  “A Kind of Magic” On Tuesday, August 18th, 2026 7 PM PT on Twitch
Noah Kahan Brings Chappell Roan on Stage for California Performance
Noah Kahan Brings Chappell Roan on Stage for California Performance
Ambition, Innovation & Ideas That Move Business Forward – NewInBooks
Ambition, Innovation & Ideas That Move Business Forward – NewInBooks
New Voices, New Worlds & Stories Made for YA Readers – NewInBooks
New Voices, New Worlds & Stories Made for YA Readers – NewInBooks
Interview with Marilee Dahlman, Author of Mall Goddess – NewInBooks
Interview with Marilee Dahlman, Author of Mall Goddess – NewInBooks
One Kiss Away: New Romance Novels to Get Lost In – NewInBooks
One Kiss Away: New Romance Novels to Get Lost In – NewInBooks
Lupita Nyongos Stylist Shares How She Put Together Those The Odyssey Press Tour Looks
Lupita Nyongos Stylist Shares How She Put Together Those The Odyssey Press Tour Looks
I Browsed My Way Into a Beauty Haul—24 Items I Shamelessly Added to My Cart This Month
I Browsed My Way Into a Beauty Haul—24 Items I Shamelessly Added to My Cart This Month
Im Giving Chic Raven: Get Ready With Stassi Schroeder for Her Premiere Party
Im Giving Chic Raven: Get Ready With Stassi Schroeder for Her Premiere Party
Summer Outfits Look So Much Chicer When Styled With This Trending Accessory
Summer Outfits Look So Much Chicer When Styled With This Trending Accessory
Sam Neill Documentary Focuses on Late Actors Horror Career
Sam Neill Documentary Focuses on Late Actors Horror Career
5 Horror Sequels That Are Actually Better Than the Original
5 Horror Sequels That Are Actually Better Than the Original
This Week in Horror: American Horror Story Reunites Its Villains, Verity Turns Nasty, and Freddy Fazbears Pizza Gets Real
This Week in Horror: American Horror Story Reunites Its Villains, Verity Turns Nasty, and Freddy Fazbears Pizza Gets Real
Bury the Devil Trailer Locks a Night Nurse in a One-Take Possession (Exclusive)
Bury the Devil Trailer Locks a Night Nurse in a One-Take Possession (Exclusive)