Music

Major Labels Beat Allegations of Bogus Takedown Notices


master mentalism tricks

A federal judge ruled Friday (April 29) that the major record labels — Universal Music Group, Sony Music Entertainment and Warner Music Group — and an anti-piracy group called Rightscorp didn’t violate any laws when they sent millions of takedown emails to internet service provider RCN.

RCN claimed the takedowns were “unsupported” and amounted to an “unlawful, unfair, and fraudulent business practice.” The labels and Rightscorp argued back that RCN’s allegation was an attempt to distract from the “rampant copyright infringement occurring on its network.”

On Friday, U.S. District Judge Michael A. Shipp sided decisively with the labels, saying there was no evidence that RCN had suffered any actual legal harms from the notices. The judge said it’s reasonable for RCN to wish Rightscorp had behaved differently, but that the anti-piracy group wasn’t legally required to do so.

“Their desire for companies like Rightscorp to tailor infringement notifications in certain ways to save internet providers money is understandable but, as it stands, no such requirement is obligated by law,” Judge Shipp wrote. “Any costs derived from internet providers’ preferences are theirs to bear alone.”

The ruling came in a broader lawsuit filed by UMG, SME and WMG that claims RCN turned a blind eye to piracy on its network, allegedly putting the ISP on the hook for millions in damages. It’s one of several similar cases filed by the labels against ISPs in courts around the country; in one of them, the labels already won a $1 billion verdict against Cox Communications.

Facing those allegations, RCN fired back with accusations of its own. It claimed that Rightscorp had violated unfair competition laws by using “sham” detection methods to flood the company with questionable takedown notices. It said the notices were aimed more at “gaining leverage” than actually pursuing real infringers.

“Instead of actually policing their copyrights … defendants seek to create an environment in which ISPs, including RCN, have no choice but to indiscriminately terminate the internet access of every customer accused of copyright infringement, or face the wrath of the record labels and the RIAA,” the company wrote.

But on Friday, Judge Shipp said RCN’s real gripe appeared to be with Congress and the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, which requires rights holders to submit a notice for each new infringement. How exactly those notices are formatted or submitted is not stipulated by the DMCA, the judge wrote.

“Even if Rightscorp could have saved internet providers ‘time and effort’ by following [RCN]’s DMCA policy, any additional costs to internet providers are based on how they chose to design their system,” the judge wrote. “At bottom, Internet Providers take issue with Congress’s statutory regime.”

Attorneys for both sides did not immediately return requests for comment on Friday.



Read The Full Article Here


trick photography
Guerdy Abraira Is Finding Her ‘Groove Back’ After Cancer Remission
Guerdy Abraira Is Finding Her ‘Groove Back’ After Cancer Remission
How Much Money He Had – Hollywood Life
How Much Money He Had – Hollywood Life
Actors Who Refuse vs. Embrace Sex Scenes
Actors Who Refuse vs. Embrace Sex Scenes
Keke Palmer Revisits Her Biggest On and Off-Screen Moments
Keke Palmer Revisits Her Biggest On and Off-Screen Moments
Disney to Close Jim Henson’s Final Muppet Project
Disney to Close Jim Henson’s Final Muppet Project
Wicked review – Grande and Erivo’s chemistry is unmatched
Wicked review – Grande and Erivo’s chemistry is unmatched
Is Arcane Over or Will There Be More Seasons?   
Is Arcane Over or Will There Be More Seasons?   
Everything New on Max in December 2024
Everything New on Max in December 2024
Major Death, Gruesome John Dutton Scenes Leave Jamie in Big Trouble
Major Death, Gruesome John Dutton Scenes Leave Jamie in Big Trouble
Landman Season 1 Episode 3 Gets Real About Green Energy and Complicated Relationships
Landman Season 1 Episode 3 Gets Real About Green Energy and Complicated Relationships
Why Is Chad Duell Leaving ‘General Hospital’? Actor Reveals Exit
Why Is Chad Duell Leaving ‘General Hospital’? Actor Reveals Exit
You’ll Need to Brace Yourself For These Heartbreaking Days of Our Lives Spoilers During The Week of 11-25-24
You’ll Need to Brace Yourself For These Heartbreaking Days of Our Lives Spoilers During The Week of 11-25-24
Adam Gontier + Matt Walst Are Excited For Future of New 3DG Music
Adam Gontier + Matt Walst Are Excited For Future of New 3DG Music
Pearl Jam Cover Temple of the Dog’s “Hunter Strike”
Pearl Jam Cover Temple of the Dog’s “Hunter Strike”
Father John Misty, Lil Wayne, Nas, and Snoop Dogg Respond to Kendrick Lamar’s Surprise New Album GNX
Father John Misty, Lil Wayne, Nas, and Snoop Dogg Respond to Kendrick Lamar’s Surprise New Album GNX
What You Didn’t See on TV at 2024 MAMA Awards
What You Didn’t See on TV at 2024 MAMA Awards
6 New Business Books for Fans of Tom Peters
6 New Business Books for Fans of Tom Peters
Book Riot’s Deals of the Day for November 24, 2024
Book Riot’s Deals of the Day for November 24, 2024
Con Artist Heists Heirloom Jewelry in Chilling Domestic Thriller
Con Artist Heists Heirloom Jewelry in Chilling Domestic Thriller
The Buzziest Books of November | 2024
The Buzziest Books of November | 2024
5 Party-Ready Trends Celebrities Are Wearing This Party Season 2024
5 Party-Ready Trends Celebrities Are Wearing This Party Season 2024
17 Amazon Beauty items Worth Buying (Especially While They’re On Sale)
17 Amazon Beauty items Worth Buying (Especially While They’re On Sale)
Kaia Gerber Resurrects the Olsens’ Favorite It Bag
Kaia Gerber Resurrects the Olsens’ Favorite It Bag
25 Elevated Basics From the Gap Pre–Black Friday Sale
25 Elevated Basics From the Gap Pre–Black Friday Sale
Martin Scorsese Loves Best Horror Film of the Year Now Streaming
Martin Scorsese Loves Best Horror Film of the Year Now Streaming
‘The Fly II’ May Be The Most Underrated Body-Horror Movie Ever
‘The Fly II’ May Be The Most Underrated Body-Horror Movie Ever
Tony Todd: Actor, Producer, Father… Icon. We will miss you.
Tony Todd: Actor, Producer, Father… Icon. We will miss you.
Remnant (2024) – Pelicula de Terror ⋆
Remnant (2024) – Pelicula de Terror ⋆